Monday, December 1, 2014

Discussions with Connections!

27/11/14





When reading the first four chapters of the book by Lois Lowry  The Giver I realized his society stops being flawless. Part by part of the book you get to know how is the life of the characters such as Jonas and Lily. For the first chapter Jonas starts making himself all of this questions like when he is talking to his parents after dinner about the ceremony of 12 and Jonas asked "Where any of the Elevens disappointed, your year?". His parents have answered his questions throughout the book. By chapter 3 we start involving more in Jonas´ father´s work; he is a nurterer. when going deeper into the story, we met Gabe ( Gabriel). He is a baby which jonas´father takes care of. For Gabe jonas´father breaks a rule and he saw the baby´s name. He also saw if he had a family. Probably if all of jonas family fond more with the baby and decide to hide him and take care of him in a hidden way they will get seviredly punished and get released.












Starting with chapter 4  Jonas goes to the house of the old.  In here we start understanding what kids do when they volunteer in different places. In each place they've got different places to work like in the house of the old they can shower them or make other activities. This time Jonas goes to meet his friends Asher and Fiona, they were bathing the eldest In this chapter we find about another rule "And nakedness too. it was against the rules for children and adults to look at anothers nakedness; but the rule did not apply to newchildren or the Old."(30). In the house of the old he met Larisa who told him about the release of Roberto. Roberto was an old man who got to their life limit and had to be released. In the book we find two types of releases which are good. One is the release of newchild, this were child who were´nt good enough. And the second release was the release of the Old, this was a thing to be proud of, as in the ceremony they retold all of their life of the released. As Larisa told Jonas, there were some of the Olds which had a meaningful life as Roberto, but also there were Olds who had a less meaningfull life as Edna who was a birthmother, yet according to Larisa she was good for nothing. To end this four chapters Jonas neither us now what happens with the released. Do they get killed? Or just expelled out of town?    

4 comments:

  1. Ana Isabel,
    On the last paragraph were you talked about how Larissa said that Edna didn´t have a meaningful life. She said this because of what her assignment was. Do you think that being a birthmother is bad considering that Edna didn´t choose her assignment and that Edna had worked many years as a laborer after her assignment time was completed?
    I think that anyone who worked hard and was happy in the society had a very meaningful life even though they didn´t have much to tell about their life the members of the society all helped the community progress.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Ana, I think youre blog has a really good analize. But I hav a question you think that been a birthmother is like not important?. I think that each person that leave in Jonas community has a perfect life and they leave happy as their form is.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Dear Ari, although you make a good point I would like to answer to you with another question, Do you think that everyone in the community is absolutely happy with their lifes?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Dani, as you and Ariana made point to the same thing, I think that you could answer my question too.

    ReplyDelete